TMS vs ERP vs fleet tracking: how to choose, and how to leave Excel

Short answer: A TMS manages transport jobs (orders, planning, dispatch, documents, job costs). An ERP manages the company's finances, purchasing and accounting. Fleet tracking (GPS telematics) shows where vehicles are and how they are driven. Transport companies usually need the TMS layer first, because that is where daily operations happen, and connect it to accounting and telematics data.

Comparison at a glance

TMS: the operational record of each job, from order to proof of delivery and billing hand-off. ERP: general ledger, invoicing, purchasing, payroll and reporting across the company. Fleet tracking: vehicle position, kilometres, driving behaviour and sometimes fuel and tachograph data.

Fleet tracking tells you where the truck is. It does not tell you which order it is carrying, whether the documents are back, or whether the trip made money. That is the TMS job.

Migrating from Excel without stopping the business

Excel is flexible but weak as a live system: no single version, no audit trail, no link between jobs, documents and costs. Migrate in steps: clean master data first (customers, vehicles, drivers, addresses), run the new system in parallel for one lane, then switch lane by lane.

Keep Excel for analysis and exports if your team likes it. The aim is to stop using it as the source of truth for jobs.

Checklist for choosing between TMS, ERP and fleet tracking

  • List the daily decisions your team makes and which system holds that data
  • Confirm how job data reaches accounting (export, integration or manual)
  • Check whether telematics kilometres can feed job costs
  • Clean customer, vehicle and driver lists before migration
  • Run one lane in parallel before switching
  • Ask vendors which integrations exist today, in writing

Relevant modules

All solutions · Contact Us

Useful tools and guides

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a TMS if I already have an ERP?

Usually yes if you run your own transport operations. ERPs handle finance well but rarely manage dispatch, drivers, proof of delivery and job-level costs in the detail a transport business needs.

Is GPS fleet tracking a TMS?

No. GPS tracking reports vehicle position and driving data. A TMS manages the jobs those vehicles carry. The two work best together.

How do I migrate from Excel to a TMS?

Clean master data, import it, run one lane in parallel for a few weeks, compare results, then switch lane by lane while keeping Excel for analysis only.